How a logo comes to life: the Valley Sawmills story

Valley Sawmills is one of Somerset’s few remaining traditional sawmills, at Holwell near Frome. They needed a brand, a website and an online shop, all ready for the Frome Show. The logo came first, because everything else hangs off it.

This is how it came to life, step by step, including the ideas that didn’t make it. If you’re thinking about a new logo for your own business, it’s the same process I’d take you through.

One: start with the yard

Valley is a working yard: logs, saws, sawdust and people who know their timber. Trade and retail customers pay the same straight price. A logo can’t give a business a personality it doesn’t have, so the job was to find one that looked like it belonged in that yard.

Two: go wide before you narrow down

The first deck I sent Valley had 3 routes and 38 versions in all.

  • Serif fonts. Playful and retro-modern, with different levels of detail.
  • Lino print texture. Clean and dirty at the same time. Modern and traditional in one logo, so you think ‘maker’ at first glance.
  • Bring back the 70s. Joyful badge logos with the texture baked in, colourful and a little disruptive.

There was also one 1950s throwback, a cartoon lumberjack called Logged & Loaded, purely for fun.

One concept from each first-round route: a stacked serif valley with a tree, a lino print valley with hills, and a 70s Valley Sawmills badge
One from each route: retro serif, lino print and a 70s badge.
All 38 first-round Valley Sawmills logo concepts on one page: serif wordmarks, lino print valleys, 70s badges and a 1950s lumberjack mascot
The whole of round one on a single page.

Going wide is cheap at this stage. A sketch costs minutes. Changing a logo once it’s on signs, vans and packaging costs a great deal more.

Every concept was drawn as an SVG vector, so any of them could go up on a billboard or shrink to a profile picture without going blurry.

Logged and Loaded: a 1950s cartoon lumberjack mascot carrying a log, drawn in red and in grey, with Valley Sawmills lettering
Logged & Loaded, the 1950s throwback. Not every idea has to be serious.

Three: show it where it will live

A logo on a white page tells you very little. So the ideas went onto caps, t-shirts, a van, a billboard, a mug and a tote bag. You find out whether a logo works when you see it on a van door from across a car park.

Valley Sawmills logo concepts mocked up on a cap and t-shirt, a roadside billboard and van, a mug and van door, and a yellow tote bag
Concepts from both rounds on clothing, vehicles and merchandise.

Four: listen, then evolve

The first deck said plainly that these were flavours of how the brand could look, and that some were rougher round the edges than others. Valley’s feedback went into a second round of evolutions.

  • I split the lino logo from its illustration, so the wordmark and the artwork could work alone or together.
  • I hand-drew a new, more prominent ‘sawmills’ to sit underneath.
  • I drew a little tree to pair with the wordmark, on its own or as a pattern.
  • I hand-drew cross sections of wood as another graphic device.
  • I made the ‘y’ friendlier.
Sketch notes showing the lino logo split into a valley sawmills wordmark and a separate round illustration
Splitting the logo from the illustration.
A serif Valley wordmark with a new sawmills underneath, next to a small hand-drawn tree
A new ‘sawmills’ and a tree to pair with it.
Hand-drawn cross sections of logs and a crosscut diagram, explored as graphic devices
Hand-drawn cross sections of wood.
Round two sketches: the tree drawn on its own, valley with a bigger sawmills underneath, the tree behind the wordmark, and a friendlier y
The last round: tree split out, bigger ‘sawmills’, friendlier y.

Five: strip it back

The logo Valley uses today is the wordmark on its own: ‘valley’ in heavy hand-drawn letters, ‘sawmills’ underneath, one colour and no frame. The tree, the texture and the badges all helped show what the brand should feel like. The finished logo only has to carry the name.

The final Valley Sawmills logo: a hand-drawn valley wordmark with sawmills underneath, shown black on white, white on green-grey and at three smaller sizes
The final logo in one colour, reversed out of the brand green-grey, and at shrinking sizes.

Fewer parts make a logo more useful. One colour means it can be printed, embroidered, engraved or stencilled without losing anything. It still reads at the size of a browser tab, which is exactly where you’ll find it on the Valley website.

The Valley Sawmills website homepage with the new logo in the header above a close-up of sawn timber
On the Valley Sawmills website today.

Six: build the toolkit around it

With the logo agreed, I built the rest of the identity around it: an earthy green-grey as the lead colour, dusty rose and burnt orange as accents, Fraunces for headlines and Inter for everything else. The website, the shop, the photography and the brand film all follow the same rules.

What this means for your logo

If you’re planning a new logo, here’s the short version. Go wide before you choose. See it on the things you’ll really use. Let feedback shape it. Then take away everything that doesn’t need to be there.

See the whole project in the Valley Sawmills case study, or book a free call.

Previous
Previous

Christmas and Small Business Saturday: a marketing plan for Kenilworth, Leamington and Warwick shops

Next
Next

Google Ads on £300 a month: a realistic plan for a Warwick District small business